Mustard Plug
Group · United States · Grand Rapids · formed 1991
Ska punk band
Timeline
1990s
Biography
Biography
Mustard Plug is an American ska punk band from Grand Rapids, Michigan, consisting of Dave Kirchgessner (vocals), Brandon Jenison (trumpet), Jim Hofer (trombone), Nate Cohn (drums), Colin Clive (guitar/vocals), Mark Petz (tenor saxophone) and Greg Witulski (bass).
Formed in 1991, the band has regularly toured throughout the United States, Europe, Japan, and South America. They have toured with the Warped Tour twice, and participated in the Ska Against Racism Tour. As of 2024, the band has released eight studio albums and continues to tour actively.
Explaining the band's goal, Jim Hofer said, "We may have some messages in our music, but essentially we just do this because we love it and we want people to lighten up and have fun."
History
The band formed in 1991 after Colin and Dave both attended a Special Beat show. The band's original members were Dave Kirchgessner, Mike McKendrick, Colin Clive, and Anthony Vilchez. There was virtually no ska scene in Grand Rapids at the time, so Mustard Plug was able to develop a unique sound and draw a large following.
Brandon Jenison stated in an interview that their band name originated when "a guy in the early stages of the band was making a sandwich and that crusty stuff that forms on the mustard bottle when you put it in the fridge without wiping it off first gave him an interesting idea for a name."
In 2002, the band released Yellow #5, and supported the album for years on tour. In 2005, they released the "greatest hits" album Masterpieces: 1991–2002.
Mustard Plug was on the label Hopeless Records for many years, but had a period of free agency until their signing with Bad Time Records.
The band celebrated their 20th anniversary in 2011 with a national tour.
In 2012, the band had an idea for a live album called Mustard Plug:Live!, but canceled in favor of their 2014 album Can't Contain It, the recording of which was funded via Kickstarter. The album features cover art by Jeff Rosenstock of Bomb the Music Industry.
In May 2017, the band performed at Pouzza Fest in Montreal. In 2019, they embarked on a tour of Japan. The band continues to perform around the United States on a regular basis. In 2021, long-time bassist Rick Johnson left the group.
On September 8, 2023, the band released Where Did All My Friends Go?, their first studio album in 9 years, on label Bad Time Records.
Line-up
Dave Kirchgessner - lead vocals (since 1991)
Colin Clive - guitar, vocals (since 1991)
Nathan Cohn - drums (since 2005)
Brandon Jenison - trumpet, backing vocals (since 1994)
Jim Hofer - trombone (since 1994)
Mark Petz - tenor saxophone (1993–1998; since 2021)
Greg Witulski - bass (since 2021)
Past members
Rick Johnson - bass (2004–2021)
Anthony Vilchez - bass (1991–1994)
Craig DeYoung - bass (1994–2001), alto saxophone (1992–1994)
Matt Van - bass (2001–2004)
Mike McKendrick - drums (1991–1993)
Michael Skowron - trombone (1993-1995), tenor saxophone (1993-1995)
Nick Varano - drums (1993–1999)
Brad Rozier - drums (1999–2004)
John Massel - drums (2004-2005)
Bob Engelsman - trombone (1992–1994)
Bleu VanDyke - trombone (1995–1998)
Kevin Dixon - tenor saxophone (1996–1998)
Albums
Skapocalypse Now! (1992, Dashiki Clout)
Big Daddy Multitude (1993, Asbestos Records)
Evildoers Beware! (1997, Hopeless Records)
Pray for Mojo (1999, Hopeless Records)
Yellow No. 5 (2002, Hopeless Records)
Masterpieces: 1991-2002 (2005, Hopeless Records)
In Black and White (2007, Hopeless Records)
Can't Contain It (2014, No Idea Records)
Where Did All My Friends Go? (2023, Bad Time Records)
Hopeless Records compilation appearances
Lolita and Never Be appear on Hopelessly Devoted to You, Vol. II (1998)
Yesterday and Already Gone appear on Hopelessly Devoted to You, Vol. 3 (2000)
Away from Here and Not Enough appear on Hopelessly Devoted to You, Vol. 4 (2002)
You and Over the Edge appear on Hopelessly Devoted to You, Vol. 6 (2006)
Discography & profile
Normalised profile
Percentiles are computed over every artist in the database, so a tier-3 artist can still sit in the 95th percentile on a single axis.
| Metric | Value | Percentile |
|---|---|---|
| Wikipedia language versions | 5 | 32th |
| Spotify monthly listeners | — | no data |
| Release groups in DB | 0 | 0th |
| Studio albums | 0 | 0th |
| Awards recorded | 0 | 0th |
| Timeline events | 1 | 40.6th |
| Recording span (years) | 35 | 74.2th |
| Genres | 2 | 74th |
Percentiles are computed at render time; missing values mean the artist has no data on that axis.
Discography (0 release groups)
No discography rows stored yet
MusicBrainz enrichment for this artist is still pending. Release groups appear here once it runs.
Stats & PK
Percentile within all 23,672 published artists.Put Mustard Plug head-to-head →
| Metric | Value | Percentile |
|---|---|---|
| Wikipedia language versions | 5 | 32th |
| Spotify monthly listeners | — | no data |
| Release groups in DB | 0 | 0th |
| Studio albums | 0 | 0th |
| Awards recorded | 0 | 0th |
| Timeline events | 1 | 40.6th |
| Recording span (years) | 35 | 74.2th |
| Genres | 2 | 74th |
Awards & honours
Where this record comes from
core—wikidata · CC0 · retrieved 10 October 2026
https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1993091genre—wikidata · CC0 · retrieved 11 October 2026
https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1993091seed-list—wikipedia · CC BY-SA 4.0 · retrieved 10 October 2026
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mustard_Plugbiography—wikipedia-en · CC BY-SA 4.0 · retrieved 10 October 2026
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mustard_Plug
Why this artist is in the database
- List of ska musicians
Tier rule: curated genre/region list
Image: no portrait (not displayed: the licence credit is missing)
Wikidata: Q1993091 · MusicBrainz: 70a692bb-dbd3-440a-af7b-c82e5e1389b2
Similar artists
Browse every Tier 3 artist →Ranked from this record's own data: shared genre tags (rarer tags weigh more), era, home country and comparable fame. Every card lists the signals that placed it — no editorial picks.

Big D and the Kids Table
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
5 wikis

Dance Hall Crashers
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
6 wikis
Kemuri
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
3 wikis
Skankin' Pickle
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
2 wikis
Starpool
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
2 wikis

Suburban Legends
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · from United States
2 wikis
Catch 22
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · debut 1996 · from United States
8 wikis
Choking Victim
United States · Group
ska punk
1 shared genre tag · debut 1994 · from United States
8 wikis